Christians sometimes wonder whether God judges people differently depending on what they know, what they have heard, or the circumstances in which they live. It is an important pastoral question, touching on issues of fairness, guilt, the spread of the gospel, and the character of God himself. Scripture is clear that God is perfectly just, perfectly consistent, and perfectly righteous. But Scripture also speaks about different kinds of knowledge, different degrees of responsibility, and even unconscious sin. How do these realities hold together?
A helpful starting point is Paul’s teaching in Romans, particularly the passages dealing with the law, sin, and judgement. Among these is Romans 4:14–15, where Paul writes, “For if it is the adherents of the law who are to be the heirs, faith is null and the promise is void. For the law brings wrath, but where there is no law there is no transgression.” At first glance this might seem to suggest that God judges differently on the basis of what people know. But to understand Paul properly, we need to zoom out.
1. All Are Under Sin, and God’s Judgement Is Impartial
Paul has already established earlier in Romans that “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (3:23). Jew and Gentile alike “are all under sin” (3:9). God does not have two standards, one for religious people and another for the irreligious. His judgement is impartial (2:11). That means God’s character does not change depending on the person before him. God’s justice does not bend for or against anyone.
However, impartiality does not mean uniformity. It is possible to judge impartially yet still account for the specific facts of each case. Human courts operate this way: the same law applies to all, but judges consider intention, knowledge, and circumstance. Scripture reveals that God likewise judges with perfect knowledge of every person’s situation, motives, and heart (1 Sam. 16:7).
2. What Does Paul Mean by “Where There Is No Law There Is No Transgression”?
This is where Romans 4:14–15 comes into play. Paul is not saying that people without the written law (i.e., Gentiles) are innocent or morally neutral. Earlier, in Romans 1–2, he has already taught that Gentiles do sin and are indeed accountable. They have the law “written on their hearts” (2:15). Though they do not possess the Mosaic Law, they still violate God’s moral will and therefore stand guilty before Him.
So what does Paul mean in Romans 4 when he says that “without the law there is no transgression”? The key is in the word transgression – a specific kind of sin. In the biblical sense, “transgression” means stepping over a known boundary. A person cannot “break” a written commandment that he has never been given. But he can still sin, and he can still be guilty of sin, because sin is fundamentally rebellion against God, whether or not it involves breaking a specific revealed statute.
In other words, all transgressions are sins, but not all sins are transgressions.
This distinction matters because it shows that Scripture acknowledges different types of sin, not different standards of judgement. God’s law is the universal moral reality that reflects his character; the Mosaic law was its historical, covenantal expression to Israel. Breaking a written commandment is one form of sin, but ignoring conscience, rejecting natural revelation, or failing to honour God as Creator are also sins (Rom. 1:21).
3. Unconscious Sin and Greater Accountability
What about unconscious or unintentional sins? Scripture recognises these as real sins. The Old Testament sacrificial system included offerings for “unintentional” sins (Lev. 4). Under the New Covenant, believers are called to confess sins they know and to seek cleansing from “hidden faults” (Ps. 19:12).
The Bible, then, does not treat unconscious sin as morally harmless. It is still sin in God’s sight. Yet God’s judgement takes into account the degree of knowledge and intention. Jesus Himself said that the servant who “knew his master’s will but did not get ready or act according to his will, will receive a severe beating,” whereas the one who “did not know, and did what deserved a beating, will receive a light beating” (Luke 12:47–48). Likewise, He declared that it would be “more bearable on the day of judgment” for Sodom than for towns that had witnessed His miracles and refused to believe (Matt. 11:22, 24).
This does not mean that the less someone knows, the less they need the gospel. Sin always separates. Unintentional sin still requires atonement. But it does reveal that God’s judgement is exquisitely just. He never overlooks sin, yet He never punishes beyond what is right.
So does God judge differently? In one sense, no:
4. God’s Judgement Is the Same, but the Circumstances Differ
- God’s standard of holiness is the same for all.
- All sin, whether conscious or unconscious, intentional or not, requires atonement.
- The way of salvation is the same for all—by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone.
- All who reject the light they are given remain accountable before Him.
But in another sense, yes:
- God judges each person according to the light they have received.
- He distinguishes between intentional rebellion and ignorant wrongdoing.
- He assesses every person’s motives, opportunities, and level of understanding.
- The degree of punishment corresponds to the degree of guilt, not the mere quantity of sins.
This is not inconsistency. It is justice.
5. Pastoral Implications
Understanding this truth guards us from two errors.
First, it prevents us from imagining that God is harsh or arbitrary. He never condemns anyone unjustly; His judgement takes everything into account. He sees what we cannot see.
Second, it keeps us from softening the seriousness of sin. Unconscious sin is still sin. Ignorance does not equal innocence. Even people who have never heard the gospel need salvation, which is why evangelism matters so deeply. Romans 3:19–20 teaches that the whole world is accountable to God, and Romans 10 reminds us that people cannot believe unless they hear.
In the end, the question “Does God judge differently?” pushes us to look to the character of God. His justice and mercy meet perfectly at the cross. Christ bore the penalty for every kind of sin—intentional, unintentional, conscious, and unconscious—for all who come to Him in faith. The Judge became the Saviour.
And that is the foundation of Christian hope: not that God goes easier on some and harder on others, but that God judges righteously and saves graciously.
Chalmers' Blog 